Video Infrastructure Review Sept 11 2007
A review of the current infrastructure for our Tandberg Video units.
IBM Global Services
Video Infrastructure
September 2007
Current status and
Recommendations
Video Overview for BSD © 2007 IBM Corporation
IBM Global Services
Overview
Introductions
What new equipment was installed
Security and Access Control
Maximum Capabilities
E.164 Alias
Futures
Best Practices for support
Best Practices for operation
Troubleshooting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Introduction
Ed Schermerhorn
– Subject Matter Expert on real-time visual communications
• Technology
• Support Practices
– 9 years in VC industry
• Many years before as an “A/V” hobbyist
– Consulted with many large and small corporations, and
educational institutions
– Most unique video communications experience:
• Resolute Bay, Canada connecting with a school in Toronto
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
What equipment was installed?
Tandberg MPS 800
Tandberg Gatekeeper
Tandberg Border Controller
New Endpoints
TMS Appliance (Procured through different
vendor)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Graphic of network
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg MPS 800
MPS = Media Processing System
– A Multipoint Conferencing Unit (MCU)
– “Video Bridge’
At School 89
Has 8 Media Blades
– Each with a separate Ethernet connection for conferencing
– Each capable of supporting 20 endpoints in Voice-Switched
conference (plan on 16 per blade for full functionality)
Also functions as an ISDN-IP Gateway
– H.320 to H.323
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg Gatekeeper
Call Control
– Bandwidth allocation
“The PBX” of the video environment
– Converts video numbers into an IP address
Installed at School 89
All endpoints and video devices should register to it
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg Border Controller
Firewall Traversal Device
– Uses only 6 ports opened outbound
• 1719 UDP
• 1720 TCP
• 2776 UDP and TCP
• 2777 UDP and TCP
– Responds to a small “keep alive” packet from Gatekeeper
– Allows for simplified connections to endpoints outside BSD
Installed at City Hall, 8th Floor computer Room
Compliant with H.460.18 standard
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg TMS appliance
TMS = Tandberg Management Suite
An appliance using a stripped version of Microsoft Windows
2003 Server
– Log on using network credentials
Has a SQL database to store call records and endpoint data
Single point of management for all devices
Configuration control for all devices
Scheduling and Reporting
Licensed for specific number of devices (100 max)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Security and Access Control
Do NOT use standard Windows updates for TMS appliance
– Tandberg releases patches on their website
TMS access
– 2 “Administrators”
– Use other categories for other users
Endpoints
– Menu password
– IP password
Call Encryption
– Requires constant bandwidth
– Recommended only for sensitive conversations
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Maximum Capabilities
Total number of endpoints connected to MPS=
– 120
Total number of endpoints that can register to
Gatekeeper =
– 125, with 25 concurrent calls
Maximum number of current firewall traversal
calls =
–5
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
E.164 Alias
Video number
Easier to remember than IP address
Recommend 5 digits for BSD
– Need to identify 3 digit reference for district offices?
1st Digit 2nd Digit 3rd Digit 4th Digit 5th Digit
Number not First digit Second Third digit System
used in of school digit of of school identifier
phone number school number (mobile,
extensions
(or ‘0’) number fixed,
desktop,
(currently
using ‘4’) etc.)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Futures
Resiliency should be built into VC infrastructure
– Multiple single points of failure
Desktop / Small Appliance
– Home bound student
– Emergency communication
Streaming and Archiving
Fieldview
– Remote view outside of a conference room
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Overview
Introductions
What new equipment was installed
Security and Access Control
Maximum Capabilities
E.164 Alias
Futures
Best Practices for support
Best Practices for operation
Troubleshooting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
History of VC support
Labor intensive
Problematic
Generally provided by Audio / Video support
organization
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Impacts of IP Convergence
Videoconferencing can not remain an island
Close integration with Data Network
Need strategy to address:
– QoS
– Bandwidth Management
– E164 Alias convention (more later)
– Streaming and casting
VC support model more like Telephony and Data
– Commodity Based
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Issues of Scale
Scheduling strategy
Call initiation strategy
Problem resolution strategy
Usage drivers
Technology decision ownership
Service oversight
Skilled support organization
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Scheduling
Reservation of resources
– Endpoint and infrastructure
– Reporting
Linked to call initiation software?
Awareness of system availability
Balance of ad hoc vs. scheduled
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Call initiation
Directory
– Naming convention
– E164 convention
– Maintain accuracy and completeness
In-room support
Automatic initiation
End user initiation
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Problem Isolation
Preventive maintenance / health check
Local vs. Central helpdesk
Division of responsibility & Allocation of
resources
Tower vs. Tier support model pitfalls
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Usage Drivers
Goals for system usage
– Objectives
– Costs Savings
Track usage and trends
End user instruction on features of equipment to
enhance experience
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Technology Ownership
Strategy for infrastructure
– Gatekeeper
– Gateway
– MCU (Multi-point Conferencing Unit)
Streaming and casting
– Data Storage
Emerging Technologies
– Internet (Firewall traversal)
– Mobile (3G)
Room layout and equipment suit recommendations
– Homogeneous vs. Heterogeneous
Funding
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Services Oversight
End user satisfaction
Future feature solicitation
Cooperation with technology ownership
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Skilled Support Organization
Knowledgeable of user’s environment
Familiar with end user interfaces
– Especially in heterogeneous environment
Able to follow repeatable and proven trouble
isolation steps
Able to escalate equipment hardware and software
flaws for manufacture resolution
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tools needed for Enterprise Support
Enterprise management software
– Available from the top endpoint manufactures
– View of all “in scope” devices
– Set enterprise standards
– “Glue” that binds all of the pieces (infrastructure and endpoints)
together
– Reporting
Test environment
– Problem isolation
– New feature testing
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Operational Best Practices Overview
Scheduling tips
Best method to add participants by telephone
Other audio tips
Camera tips
Presentations
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Scheduling tips
Book More time than you think you will need.
– VC meetings (in some enterprises) often “run over”
without impacting other teams
Clearly indicate to all participants that it will be a
video meeting
Have a plan for those that are not able to be on
video.
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Best Method to add Audio participants
To allow all meeting participants to hear each
other, the telephone participant should be added
from the VC system, not a speaker phone in the
room.
– Local room participants would be able to hear all
participants, but those on telephone and VC would
not be able to hear each other.
Connect any audio participants through TMS
schedule
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Other Audio Tips
Speak in a normal volume while facing the table or
display.
Avoid tapping on table or rustling papers on the
conference table
Keep cellular phones and Blackberries away from
microphones
– Don’t place on table
– Causes stutter audio tone that is heard at remote
locations, not in the local room
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Camera Tips
Close shades on any windows in meeting room
– Will create only silhouettes of meeting participants
Avoid red colored clothing
Avoid busy prints on clothing
Face the camera when speaking
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
General Videoconference operations
A message will appear on screen twice before end
of meeting if scheduled through TMS
– 5 minutes
– 1 minute
– If the system is not booked for another meeting, you will
have an option to extend the meeting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Presentations
Can be sent directly from laptop through VC
system
Avoid busy backgrounds
Limit animation and builds in Powerpoint
Presentations
Use high contrast between background and text
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Thank you for your time
We look forward to
helping you!
Video Overview for BSD © 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Infrastructure
September 2007
Current status and
Recommendations
Video Overview for BSD © 2007 IBM Corporation
IBM Global Services
Overview
Introductions
What new equipment was installed
Security and Access Control
Maximum Capabilities
E.164 Alias
Futures
Best Practices for support
Best Practices for operation
Troubleshooting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Introduction
Ed Schermerhorn
– Subject Matter Expert on real-time visual communications
• Technology
• Support Practices
– 9 years in VC industry
• Many years before as an “A/V” hobbyist
– Consulted with many large and small corporations, and
educational institutions
– Most unique video communications experience:
• Resolute Bay, Canada connecting with a school in Toronto
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
What equipment was installed?
Tandberg MPS 800
Tandberg Gatekeeper
Tandberg Border Controller
New Endpoints
TMS Appliance (Procured through different
vendor)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Graphic of network
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg MPS 800
MPS = Media Processing System
– A Multipoint Conferencing Unit (MCU)
– “Video Bridge’
At School 89
Has 8 Media Blades
– Each with a separate Ethernet connection for conferencing
– Each capable of supporting 20 endpoints in Voice-Switched
conference (plan on 16 per blade for full functionality)
Also functions as an ISDN-IP Gateway
– H.320 to H.323
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg Gatekeeper
Call Control
– Bandwidth allocation
“The PBX” of the video environment
– Converts video numbers into an IP address
Installed at School 89
All endpoints and video devices should register to it
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg Border Controller
Firewall Traversal Device
– Uses only 6 ports opened outbound
• 1719 UDP
• 1720 TCP
• 2776 UDP and TCP
• 2777 UDP and TCP
– Responds to a small “keep alive” packet from Gatekeeper
– Allows for simplified connections to endpoints outside BSD
Installed at City Hall, 8th Floor computer Room
Compliant with H.460.18 standard
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tandberg TMS appliance
TMS = Tandberg Management Suite
An appliance using a stripped version of Microsoft Windows
2003 Server
– Log on using network credentials
Has a SQL database to store call records and endpoint data
Single point of management for all devices
Configuration control for all devices
Scheduling and Reporting
Licensed for specific number of devices (100 max)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Security and Access Control
Do NOT use standard Windows updates for TMS appliance
– Tandberg releases patches on their website
TMS access
– 2 “Administrators”
– Use other categories for other users
Endpoints
– Menu password
– IP password
Call Encryption
– Requires constant bandwidth
– Recommended only for sensitive conversations
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Maximum Capabilities
Total number of endpoints connected to MPS=
– 120
Total number of endpoints that can register to
Gatekeeper =
– 125, with 25 concurrent calls
Maximum number of current firewall traversal
calls =
–5
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
E.164 Alias
Video number
Easier to remember than IP address
Recommend 5 digits for BSD
– Need to identify 3 digit reference for district offices?
1st Digit 2nd Digit 3rd Digit 4th Digit 5th Digit
Number not First digit Second Third digit System
used in of school digit of of school identifier
phone number school number (mobile,
extensions
(or ‘0’) number fixed,
desktop,
(currently
using ‘4’) etc.)
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Futures
Resiliency should be built into VC infrastructure
– Multiple single points of failure
Desktop / Small Appliance
– Home bound student
– Emergency communication
Streaming and Archiving
Fieldview
– Remote view outside of a conference room
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Overview
Introductions
What new equipment was installed
Security and Access Control
Maximum Capabilities
E.164 Alias
Futures
Best Practices for support
Best Practices for operation
Troubleshooting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
History of VC support
Labor intensive
Problematic
Generally provided by Audio / Video support
organization
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Impacts of IP Convergence
Videoconferencing can not remain an island
Close integration with Data Network
Need strategy to address:
– QoS
– Bandwidth Management
– E164 Alias convention (more later)
– Streaming and casting
VC support model more like Telephony and Data
– Commodity Based
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Issues of Scale
Scheduling strategy
Call initiation strategy
Problem resolution strategy
Usage drivers
Technology decision ownership
Service oversight
Skilled support organization
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Scheduling
Reservation of resources
– Endpoint and infrastructure
– Reporting
Linked to call initiation software?
Awareness of system availability
Balance of ad hoc vs. scheduled
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Call initiation
Directory
– Naming convention
– E164 convention
– Maintain accuracy and completeness
In-room support
Automatic initiation
End user initiation
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Problem Isolation
Preventive maintenance / health check
Local vs. Central helpdesk
Division of responsibility & Allocation of
resources
Tower vs. Tier support model pitfalls
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Usage Drivers
Goals for system usage
– Objectives
– Costs Savings
Track usage and trends
End user instruction on features of equipment to
enhance experience
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Technology Ownership
Strategy for infrastructure
– Gatekeeper
– Gateway
– MCU (Multi-point Conferencing Unit)
Streaming and casting
– Data Storage
Emerging Technologies
– Internet (Firewall traversal)
– Mobile (3G)
Room layout and equipment suit recommendations
– Homogeneous vs. Heterogeneous
Funding
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Services Oversight
End user satisfaction
Future feature solicitation
Cooperation with technology ownership
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Skilled Support Organization
Knowledgeable of user’s environment
Familiar with end user interfaces
– Especially in heterogeneous environment
Able to follow repeatable and proven trouble
isolation steps
Able to escalate equipment hardware and software
flaws for manufacture resolution
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Tools needed for Enterprise Support
Enterprise management software
– Available from the top endpoint manufactures
– View of all “in scope” devices
– Set enterprise standards
– “Glue” that binds all of the pieces (infrastructure and endpoints)
together
– Reporting
Test environment
– Problem isolation
– New feature testing
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Operational Best Practices Overview
Scheduling tips
Best method to add participants by telephone
Other audio tips
Camera tips
Presentations
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Scheduling tips
Book More time than you think you will need.
– VC meetings (in some enterprises) often “run over”
without impacting other teams
Clearly indicate to all participants that it will be a
video meeting
Have a plan for those that are not able to be on
video.
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Best Method to add Audio participants
To allow all meeting participants to hear each
other, the telephone participant should be added
from the VC system, not a speaker phone in the
room.
– Local room participants would be able to hear all
participants, but those on telephone and VC would
not be able to hear each other.
Connect any audio participants through TMS
schedule
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Other Audio Tips
Speak in a normal volume while facing the table or
display.
Avoid tapping on table or rustling papers on the
conference table
Keep cellular phones and Blackberries away from
microphones
– Don’t place on table
– Causes stutter audio tone that is heard at remote
locations, not in the local room
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Camera Tips
Close shades on any windows in meeting room
– Will create only silhouettes of meeting participants
Avoid red colored clothing
Avoid busy prints on clothing
Face the camera when speaking
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
General Videoconference operations
A message will appear on screen twice before end
of meeting if scheduled through TMS
– 5 minutes
– 1 minute
– If the system is not booked for another meeting, you will
have an option to extend the meeting
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Presentations
Can be sent directly from laptop through VC
system
Avoid busy backgrounds
Limit animation and builds in Powerpoint
Presentations
Use high contrast between background and text
© 2007 IBM Corporation
Video Overview for BSD
IBM Global Services
Thank you for your time
We look forward to
helping you!
Video Overview for BSD © 2007 IBM Corporation
Phonics Express Training Document
VC troubleshooting flow chart(9-07)
Installing HP1100 Network Printers
Control PCs via ARD and AppleScript
Solution Safari and esis- reports not showing
Podcasting In The Classroom Presentation Files
91 Harcourt Website Follow-up with Donna and Scott